Thursday, July 22, 2010 ♥
MM Lee on flooding - Shu Wei ♥ 11:42 PM
SINGAPORE - The Singapore government's measures to reduce the impact of recent floods on homes and businesses were insufficient, the island's founding father Lee Kuan Yew said in remarks published Thursday.
Lee, commenting on Wednesday after Singapore suffered three bouts of severe flooding since mid-June, added that constant rain and limited land area made it difficult to totally prevent floods in the tropical city-state.
"How can you say that the response is sufficient?" Lee was quoted as saying by the Straits Times when asked if the government's measures to alleviate the flooding had been up to standard.
"Of course, Singaporeans expect everything to be perfect - which we try to do, but there are some things which are beyond that."
The 86-year-old former prime minister and now minister mentor, said Singapore's small land area made it difficult to deal with "acts of God."
Singapore used to be an exception in a region plagued by disasters but the recent flash floods have caused serious property damage and disrupted lives across the island, denting its reputation for urban management.
Critics have blasted the Public Utilities Board (PUB) for not being prepared to handle the first two floods, while the department defended itself by saying abnormal weather conditions and clogged drains were to blame.
Officials have vowed to improve the drainage network and step up alert systems to forewarn residents and businesses to limit the impact of future floods.
The government has identified 52 flood-prone zones, including the financial district and the Orchard Road shopping belt, and some establishments including luxury shops have resorted to installing unsightly sandbag barricades.
"There is a limited amount of space that you can dig underground, limited amount of space that you can have run-offs for canals," Lee noted.
"Whatever we do when we get extraordinary rains like we had recently, no amount of engineering can prevent flooding... unless you want to lose half the roads and have canals."
SW Comments –
It is impossible to prevent any flooding MM Lee said. That is due to limited amount of space the government could build for drainage system.
During this month, I had notice 3 occasions of flooding in Singapore, the worst has happened to Lucky Plaza in Orchard Road. Many shops in the districts had been affected. From the beginning, the officials said that the flooding was caused by blockage of drainage canals underground. The PUB sent people to clean the underground drainage system.
Since the first flood has occurred, several other flash flood has also occurred. I think that the main problem is the long heavy rain. Every time it rains, the duration of the rain is very long. Many people blamed the PUB for recent floods, I understand their behavior. If my property was destroyed by the floods, I would also blame it on somebody for my loss. In their case, they had blamed PUB.
PUB had sent workers to maintain the drainage recently; however the problem could not be stopped. Thus, I agree with MM Lee that if the extraordinary rain continues, it would be impossible to prevent flooding.
I could suggest an improvement to the PUB. Every time if it rains heavily, the PUB could direct a portion of water to other drains, thus the main cannels have enough capacity to store all the water.